Thursday, May 28, 2009
UNITED to stay DIVIDED
"United to stay Divided" might sound as an oxymoron to many, but isn't paradox the most fitting word to describe the hypocrisy with which we spend our lives?? Philosophy(Theology in particular) has myriad works to boast of to proclaim the equality of men and the creation of an egalitarian society. The message has been straight and clear: human beings are all equal and they should pursue a symbiotic relationship. The Communists,atheists themselves, are the biggest exponents of egalitarianism (talk of paradox !!! ).
Since time immemorial, there has been division in the human society. The yardsticks have varied or rather unfortunately piled up in number to come up with a novel way each time to divide the species. Talking specifically of India, what started as four sects of society -Kshatriya, Brahmin, Vaishya and Sudra, has persisted with multitudinous more sub classifications to exacerbate the situation. Now , we're divided on the grounds of religion, caste, creed, colour,community, economic status,gender,class, geography,intelligence and what not. Its ostensible in a way, that a school of thought is devoted for this purpose only and have nothing better to do.
Reservation issue has been the most talked about topic in modern India and it is the only topic that the youths is , apart from cricket and movies. It has evoked a wide range of reactions in the past decade or two; seemingly a favorite darling of conferences and live debates. But, the issue is a classic paragon of how divided and shallow we're from within. When the entire political circle was united in dividing the country on the basis of social class (mind you not economic else that'd have debunked the real BPL figure much to the chagrin of the people in power), the opposing students or a paltry section of the Intelligentsia never resisted with a united uproar. The incidents of resistance were sporadic and imbued,it involved only the ones who had to bear the brunt immediately and thus the resistance fell like a pack of cards.It died down like our first Sepoy Mutiny in 1857 and for the same reason- intermittent and diffused renegade(Some people never learn from history!!). So the proponents of division were united and the apostles of unity were divided- a grim yet an inevitable cliche.
India has enticed many foreign invaders over centuries to commit blitzkrieg and vandalize us of our resources. A different aspect of this is that it has allowed India to be a potpourri of different religions and communities; which has ameliorated the ethnic fabric of the country but the friction has been tantamount as well. People have been divided on this ground for ages(the independence struggle being a slight exception; still the inception of Muslim League is a testimony to the fact), and the situation has aggravated in the last three decades where communal hatred has ripped apart the once proud standing secular fabric of the Indian Republic.
Communal extremism has seen its peak over the years and with a disguised cloak of fundamentalism, they've amassed people with themselves by shamming as the Evangelists of their rights. And we have no right to blame the authorities for it, because they are people like us and though its difficult to accept, but deep down we all want division in the society. We all are united to the T to promote division.
We've been born and brought up in an environment where circumstantially we do a lot of things that promote division. Like most of us believe in friendship among equals and this gospel has been preached to us since we're infants. Earlier in school, it's on the basis of intelligence that parents want their kids to be with the best or someone at par with their ward's intelligence and later the dogmas keep adding up.
Here's just a simple day to day situation which showcases an unusual way of division (many may frown over it).Fancy the situation that a girl meets with an accident, its very courteous of people around to spring into action like a lightening to make sure she's fine. But when its a guy to fall off his vehicle, the number of volunteers to help plummets by a surprisingly steep number; sometimes even touching the nil mark. Now, i'm not a chauvinist and this may seem as a paltry instance to mention, but this comes out of personal experience and what people around me have faced themselves and we all cant be wrong. It is certainly very important to be courteous to ladies, but the guys deserve some attention at least when in an excruciating situation. Maybe a less germane example to many, but it is veracious for sure.
If one looks within to introspect their own behaviour towards their servants, janitors, drivers or simply the less privileged; the picture becomes conspicuously clear. We all are the followers of a theory which we condemn ourselves. maybe its easier to digest and accept this harsh reality that we are hypocrites to the core. We all love to DIVIDE AND RULE (within our limited capabilities of course).
The entire phenomenon of Capitalism is a prima facie of inequality where in the world is divided on the basis of being rich or poor. It may again seem as a macabre belief, but i see less evil in it because they openly propagate what they do. There are no pretensions of being here for only the welfare of people. Instead they are more beneficial for the society as eventually their avarice for more is giving back more to the society( Read : The Invisible Hand). Thus avarice is a deadly sin, but put hypocrisy on the other side of the court and I'm sure it'd beat avarice to emerge as the undisputed winner in the game of "The Ultimate Sin".
Racial Discrimination is certainly the worst of it all. Even after the long fought battle against apartheid which led to a historic victory, even after realization of Martin Luther King's " I have a dream" with the appointment of US President Barrack Obama at the helm of affairs, racial discrimination persists. The headlines in the media "A black man becomes US President" itself is a quintessence of racism. We admit or not, racism exists ubiquitously, but thankfully the cognizance against it is on a high and we can hope that the menace would see its nemesis and meet an end soon.
Geographic discrimination is an absurd phenomenon;especially when its within the same country. And its preposterous when its done in a country like India which gives a fundamental right to its people to move freely across any part of the country and get employed anywhere at any place in the country. But, the ludicrous act is being done in a brazen manner: MNS's recent spree against north Indians and Shiv Sena's movement against South Indians in the 70's being the instances that come to the top of one's mind.
So it has been done in the past and it may persist in the future. We've been united to stay divided for long now and either we leave the dream of an egalitarian society or at least be honest enough to stop propagating it creating futile hope amongst people. I don't want to sound dystopian but lets face it, some dreams are just not meant to be realized. The reason is not because they are chimerical, but because we are just not ready to face the reality.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 comments:
i agree with everything that you have said but i beg 2 differ on the count that the divide in the past 2 decades has decreased..today there are no major political movements that are active 2day..
as always brilliantly written sire!!
i do agree wid u krishnakant...especially d accident nd d frenshpwala paras...very true indeed!!!
But d very best part of dis blog is d clip whch shws dat religion nd politics add up to make gvnt...
d pic itself says it all...
really gud work done here!
Well Said !!!. But with changing times , we are changing . From those times of casteism and untouchability we have come a long way today .
The problem with people in India , believe me , is they are mean . You have to agree to that . Until and unless the issue does not directly affects , no one really cares about it :(
Stupid Politicians worked upon for the vote bank with the reservation policy and a nation of billion fools did not even realize the masterpiece work done by the politicians
I would also like to point one more division in the society , that of a boy and that of a girl . Although people say that women have progressed in this world , it is just a myth . In real life , women are being abused and are not given a fair deal in everything.
This divide is one of the biggest problem which stops India from being progressive , but i still get amazed at the fact that how people irrespective of any division , do come together in times of trouble , like the recent Mumbai attacks
You have very well shown that the root problem of this division is the nature of the aam aadmi himself :)
Bravo
Aristotle said that humans are social animals, and therefore we like to live within the society. For Hobbes, human nature is essentially anti-social: people are essentially egoistic, and this egoism makes life difficult in the natural state of things. If we observe, both of these statements are very true, but how can two contradictory statements be true simultaneously. As being student of science I will predict it as dualism. Human society is very dualistic in nature. For example, every human wants to live in the society but also wants to get rid of it. The article "United to stay Divided” is also proving dualistic nature of human and society. However inside the article, Mr. Ice Man is more likely opinionated Hobbes point of view (anti-social nature).
Dear friend Krish, It is one of the best blog I have ever seen. Excellent Work! *****
ya you are right..though we boast about being egalitarian there are many incidences that actually show that its just superficial...especially i would adduce the political parties..though they talk about secularism but the fact comes out during election period..when they try to propitiate the voters by bringing up the topics like ram mandir n all...(they can stoop to that level!!).. Secularism does not obviously mean a state where religion is discouraged..but making religion as their propaganda is obviously disappointing...and more disappointing is fact that no exception exists to this...
The tribulation of 26/11 is indomitable...It was the day I saw the actual ‘unity’...be it Maharashtra,Uttarpradesh,M.P,A.P,East India,west india,north or south...all had tears in their eyes..no one spoke about whether maharashtrian died or northindian...everyone was worried about INDIAN(to be more precise..about Innocent)... but as you have mentioned rightly that our so called government is actually made up of Politics+Religion..so they ought to make it a religious issue...
Almost every where it has spread its web...they have not even left the educational institutions...i mean...wake up!!!!its high time that we must actually end these reservations ...it has become a cliché.. We need a BIGGG change..an aberration..
You have actually mentioned it ALL by the name ‘united to stay divided’ ...trust me..all my votes go to you..stupendously written!!!i actually agree with every word you wrote...actually thats the best about your articles..u connect to every youth..keep up the great work!!It was a master piece to read...
I do agree with u… But I think u should consider both sides of coin. u r considering only one side i.e. we all love to DIVIDE AND RULE but u also mentioned that India to be a potpourri of different religions and communities; u take any incident and most of the times u only see Unity… MNS's and Shiv Sena's movements are some incidents that might affect unity but its not always true.. Never think hard about past, it brings “Tears”.. Don’t think more about future, it brings “Fears”.. Live the present..
And about the appointment of US President Barrack Obama whatever be the reaction of media but truth is it wont change the reality… we should believe that “EVERY CLOUD HAS SILVER LINING” so better to think it is never too late to mend..
Really great work done…
Keep it up……
first of all let me praise you for envisaging such a broad picture of the categorical world that we are living in. truly the idea "United to stay Divided" has been exemplified very aptly..though u have been a bit grandiloquent on expressing it,but i understand its meant for the esoteric.
more over illustration of the division of the society into four classes to the consequences being reservations for narrowing the relegated differences in this era is commendable.
Amidst all the foreign invaders entering to devastate and undermine the indian subcontinent is the quintessence of the concept being applicable globally.
And communal extremism which is like haemoglobin in our blood, the paucity of which necessitates political conglomerates like Shiv Sena and MNS to rejuvinate by increasing the jeremiad of the opposites.Which as you said also forms a perfect mixture of religion and politics.
Also it is rightly said by you about the esoteric grouping of infants in the education system is like a pandemic disease amongst parents.
Though aparthied was extirpated long back,specially in South Africa where it was nurtured heavily,the system's adaptation world wide has yet not extinguished. Look at indian students in Australia being juxtaposed to vulnerability and now even in other parts of the world is what exemplifies racial enimity.Which is also why Obama's achievement was termed as a black's achievement.More over it is highly disgusting to see the same happening within a country.
One crucial idea where i see as the Divide and Rule policy perfectly working is the US's extreme intervention in the settlement of the kashmir issue between India and Pakistan. Which indirectly allows it to persevere its hold over the never ending issue and stimulate hostility between the two neighbours.
hence now,to me, it seems like we need to get habitual to the the idiosyncracy of the overall system.
very well written sir...!!!
and i agree to it... there is discrimination...out an dout...
recent racist attacks in australia prove that.
One point about the MNS...that doesn't seem to be discrimination...its just that they are trying to improve their standing in their own state..you see mumbai ...it really does not seem much like maharashtra...i think that the MNS may have a point...only thing is that there approach is completely wrong...atrocious infact...they say that the maharashtrians are not being given a fair chance in their own state...what they don't see is that it was them who lost out...the people from other states have a better standing in maharashtra only because the maharashtrians were slack or lackadaisical...
i have heard many anecdotes recently to prove that ..
lol
lovely writeup
:D
Post a Comment